Skip to content
Back Porch

How things work at Back Porch

The plain story of what happens between a customer writing a review and you reading it, and what a business can and can’t do along the way.

After you press submit

Say you’ve just written about your mechanic and pressed submit. The review doesn’t go up right away. It waits as pending until one of our moderators has read it against the review guidelines, and then it is either published or turned down. Until it is published, a review never shows on the company’s page and never counts toward its score.

The moderator checks that the writer really dealt with this company, whether that meant an order, a booking, a visit or a quote. Anything that doesn’t belong in a review gets taken out: links, phone numbers, personal details about employees, threats, hate speech. They keep an eye out for one person posting many times, and for reviews quietly written by the company’s staff or by a competitor. And they hold everyone to one review of the same company per 30 days.

Businesses get to answer any review in public. What they can’t do is edit, hide or delete one, or pay to have it handled differently. A one-star review goes through the very same steps as a five-star one.

The arithmetic behind a score

There’s nothing fancy about a company’s score. We take the stars from its published reviews, add them up, divide by how many reviews there are and round to one decimal place. We don’t estimate, nobody’s payment tips the scale, and no one adjusts a score by hand.

A score only gets its color once there are at least 5 published reviews. Before that you’ll still see the number, on a plain background and labeled “Early days,” because two or three reviews can tip either way.

The word we useAverageHow it looks
Delightful4.5 – 5.04.7
Satisfying4.0 – 4.44.2
So-so3.0 – 3.93.4
Rocky2.0 – 2.92.5
Dreadful1.0 – 1.91.6

A score for buying, a score for service

Everyone who writes a review tells us whether they bought something, asked for a price, or had work done. Once enough people have answered, a company gets two separate scores, one for buying and one for service. A shop can sell you a fine lawn mower and still be slow to fix it.

Beyond the stars: the details and the bill

Reviewers can also give stars for four things: being honest and easy to reach, what it cost, getting the job done, and whether it was as good as promised. They can tell us whether the final price matched the quote and whether any charge came out of nowhere. None of these appear on a company’s page until 5 customers have answered that question.

Putting lists in order

When a list is sorted by rating, we don’t go by the average alone. If we did, a company with three five-star reviews would sit above one with forty reviews averaging 4.8. So every company begins with 5 pretend reviews of 3.5 stars each, and its real reviews outweigh them more and more as they come in:

place in line = (3.5 × 5 + all its stars) ÷ (5 + all its reviews)

That number is only used to line lists up. The score you see on a company’s page is always its straight average.

Where each review started

  • Shared first-hand on Back Porch: the customer wrote it right here on this site.
  • Passed along from the company's own feedback form: one of the company’s customers filled it in, and the company handed it on to us. Anything hand-picked, altered or bought by the company, we refuse.
  • From another review site: the customer first posted it somewhere else, and we show it here just as it appeared there.

How a listing gets made

Each listing starts from business details we collect and then check: name, street address, phone number, website. When a business shuts its doors, or we can’t confirm the listing any longer, it is hidden from view but not deleted, and every review on it is kept.

A company can claim its page at no cost, to fix its details and answer customers. Claiming has no effect on the score.

Spotted a bad review?

Each review has a Report link beneath it. Use it for a review that breaks the guidelines, belongs to a different company, or strikes you as fake. Someone on our moderation team reads every report and decides: the review stays, the review goes, or we ask its writer to tell us more. It remains visible the whole time we’re deciding.