Skip to content
Back Porch

Review guidelines

A good review is your own, it’s specific, and it’s fair. The same rules hold for every reviewer and every business.

What helps a review

  • Your own dealings, and fairly recent. Only write about a company you dealt with yourself (you bought something, hired them, booked them or asked them for a quote), and not too long ago: within about the last few years.
  • Details over adjectives. “Great service” tells the next customer very little. “They quoted $400, charged $400 and finished a day early” tells them a lot. So say what you bought or had done, whether the final price matched the quote, whether it was on time, and how they handled any problem.
  • Honest, and decent about it. Describe what happened and how you were treated. Strong feelings are fine; name-calling isn’t.
  • Long enough to be worth reading. Somewhere from 40 to 3,000 characters.

Reviews we turn away

  • Reviews by people who work for the company or for a rival, by members of their families, or by anyone paid by either business.
  • Reviews written to get something back: a discount, a gift, money, a chance in a prize draw, or any other reward.
  • Reviews that are really about someone else: a different company, the maker of a product, a marketplace seller or a payment service.
  • More than one review of a company from you in any 30-day stretch.
  • Links of any kind, and phone numbers or email addresses.
  • An employee’s full name, or any way to contact them.
  • Threats or harassment, hate speech, sexual content, or curse words thrown at a person.
  • Words borrowed from another source, or generated by an AI tool, rather than your own account of what happened.
  • Accusations of a crime. Take those to the authorities. You’re still free to describe what happened to you.

For the businesses we list

We’re glad when a business asks every one of its customers for a review. Here is what a business must never do:

  • Hold out a reward of any kind for a review, or for a favorable one.
  • Ask for reviews only from customers it expects to be pleased, or nudge disappointed ones not to write.
  • Post reviews of its own business or a rival’s, whether the owner does it or hands the job to employees, family members or an outside agency.
  • Pressure or threaten anyone into editing or deleting what they wrote.

We drew these rules from 16 CFR Part 465, the Federal Trade Commission’s regulation on consumer reviews and testimonials. Get a review by breaking them, and we’ll take it off the site.

Disagree with a decision?

Every review written on Back Porch gets read by a moderator before anyone else sees it, and when one is turned down, the reason goes on file. Write to us with the name of the company and the email address you reviewed with, and someone will look at it again.